- This topic has 27 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 5 years, 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Which is which? What are your color settings in Lightroom, more importantly, do they match Photoshop? Why the use of ProPhoto as RGB working space? Do you softproof?
I think I have figured it out. I’ve set both programs to ProPhoto RGB and I get equal results now. Not sure why photoshop was showing different colors before.
It’s definitely because of the calibration, because before the calibration I was geting equal colors. I didn’t change any settings in lightroom or photoshop after the calibration, just now when I noticed the color difference.
Did you restart the programs after installing your display profile so that they can pick up on the changes?
Did you restart the programs after installing your display profile so that they can pick up on the changes?
Yes. I only started working with photos 2 days after calibration.
Damn, I just reviewed couple more photos and I still see some minor difference….I don’t know what it is at this point…
Did you restart the programs after installing your display profile so that they can pick up on the changes?
It’s weird, on some photos I see the color difference on some the color is perfectly equal. Images shot on the same camera, same lens, same settings.
I’m working on old black and white paper photos.
Sounds like a Lightroom bug to me. How do you open the photos in PS? “Edit in PS” from LR, Bridge, or Windows Explorer?
Sounds like a Lightroom bug to me. How do you open the photos in PS? “Edit in PS” from LR, Bridge, or Windows Explorer?
I right click a photo from lightroom and then Edit in Adobe photoshop.
Ok. Instead of doing that, save to 16-bit TIFF in LR and open from explorer in PS. Does that help?
Ok. Instead of doing that, save to 16-bit TIFF in LR and open from explorer in PS. Does that help?
Photoshop still shows its own colors. Maybe it has something to do with the RAW CR2 files that I’m working?
Ok. Instead of doing that, save to 16-bit TIFF in LR and open from explorer in PS. Does that help?
Also I have noticed that the color difference is only noticable on B&W photos. It still sucks to work on a photo for so long in lightroom only to take it to photoshop for cleaning and get completely different look..
That’s very clearly a Lightroom or Photoshop bug then. I’d take it to Adobe.
I think it’s lightroom alone, the color changes even when exporting directly from it, tried every color space.
Anyways, I will have to read a lot about this issue on google, thank you for helping me.
That’s very clearly a Lightroom or Photoshop bug then. I’d take it to Adobe.
Interesting thing to note is that when I convert the colors to CMYK mode in photoshop they appear the same as in lightroom.
